Rye whiskey, first distilled in 1750, played a crucial role in the early history of the United States. With George Washington himself owning a rye distillery that produced an impressive amount of whiskey, rye was once the dominant spirit in the country. However, the arrival of Prohibition in the 1920s nearly wiped out the rye whiskey market. As bootleggers turned to corn-based bourbon and moonshine, the popularity of rye dwindled. Even after Prohibition was overturned in 1933, rye whiskey struggled to regain its former glory, with cheap Canadian whiskeys masquerading as ryes flooding the market.
Fortunately, the cocktail and craft distilling scene of the new millennium has sparked a revival of rye whiskey. Bars now offer a variety of rye-based cocktails, and store shelves are stocked with exciting new bottles of rye whiskey. This resurgence has led to a renewed interest in this historically significant spirit. But with so many options available, discerning drinkers may wonder which bottles are worth seeking out.
One way to identify the finest rye whiskeys is through prestigious competitions like the San Francisco World Spirits Competition. This event, known as the “Oscars of the Spirits World,” brings together top-quality spirits for blind taste testing by esteemed judges. Here are five standout rye whiskeys that are vying for the Best in Class Rye Whisky Award:
Based in Cleveland, Ohio, River Roots Barrel Company is dedicated to producing high-quality American whiskeys that combine modern appeal with traditional techniques. Their Straight Rye Whiskey impressed judges with its flavors of cinnamon, clove, vanilla, and caramel.
Tumblin’ Dice, known for its innovative blends and exceptional quality, continues to impress with its Curated Small Batch Straight Rye Whiskey. Exhibiting notes of dried fruit, spice, caramel, and vanilla, this whiskey reflects the brand’s commitment to excellence.
Dark Arts Whiskey House in Lexington, Kentucky, stands out for its unique maturation and blending techniques. By incorporating toasted Amburana Oak staves into their Straight Rye Whiskey, they have created a complex and aromatic spirit that caught the judges’ attention.
A newcomer on the scene, Penelope Bourbon has quickly gained a loyal following for its innovative approach and top-notch ingredients. Their Toasted Straight Rye Whiskey, with notes of honey, vanilla, and spice, is a prime example of the brand’s commitment to quality and craftsmanship.
From the shores of Daufuskie Island in South Carolina comes Tabby Road’s Single Barrel Rye #1B. This high-proof rye whiskey is designed to showcase the bold and spicy flavors that rye is known for, with notes of spice, vanilla, oak, dark chocolate, caramel, and more.
As the rye whiskey market experiences a resurgence, these standout bottles offer a glimpse into the innovation and quality that define the modern rye whiskey landscape. Whether enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or in a classic cocktail, these rye whiskeys embody the rich history and enduring appeal of this storied spirit.